Ghost jobs: what they are, how common, and how to spot one
Short answer: a ghost job is a posting the company has no real plan to fill soon. Estimates vary, but an analysis by Greenhouse put them at roughly 18% to 22% of postings. Warning signs: the role has been up for months, it keeps being reposted, and nobody at the company can tell you about it.
How common are they?
Numbers vary because they measure different things. Greenhouse estimated that 18% to 22% of job postings were ghost jobs (Quartz). In a Resume Builder survey, 39% of hiring managers said their company had posted a fake listing in the past year. Most of these figures come from companies that sell hiring services, so treat them as rough.
What our data shows
We can't see intent, but we can see two signs. First, age: of open roles with a posting date, 35% have been up for more than 45 days. Second, reposts: 4,686 open roles (3.0%) closed and came back under a new posting, 593 of them three times or more, and one 160 times.
Neither sign proves a ghost job. Evergreen roles (support, sales, nursing) are reposted on purpose because companies hire for them all year. But a niche role posted for four months and reposted three times deserves a question before you spend an evening on it.
Why companies post them
- To collect resumes for future openings ("pipeline building").
- The role was frozen but nobody took the posting down.
- An internal candidate is already chosen, but the role must be posted.
- To look like the company is growing.
A 2-minute checklist
| Probably real | Be careful | |
|---|---|---|
| Posting age | Under 30 days | Over 60 days |
| Reposts | First posting | Reposted several times |
| Details | Team, manager, salary range | Vague duties, no team |
| Company news | Hiring, funding, growth | Layoffs or a hiring freeze |
| A person | Recruiter replies or is named | Nobody can say who hires |
What to do
- Apply to fresh roles first. Most applications arrive in a role's first four days, so new postings are both more likely real and less crowded.
- For older postings, message the recruiter or hiring manager before you tailor anything.
- Don't take silence personally. A ghost job wastes your time; it says nothing about you.
HiredEarly marks roles that were reposted, says how many times, and flags roles open for more than 45 days, so you can decide with the facts in front of you.
How we counted. A repost is a role that closed and came back at the same company with the same title under a new posting. Age uses the posting date each board publishes. Our numbers cover the 1,168 employers HiredEarly tracks, read from their own job boards on November 7, 2026, not the whole job market.
Questions people ask
What is a ghost job?
A job posting for a role the company has no real plan to fill soon, for example to collect resumes or because a frozen role was never taken down.
How many job postings are ghost jobs?
An analysis by Greenhouse estimated 18% to 22%. Other surveys give higher numbers, but they measure different things.
How can you tell if a job posting is fake?
Check how long it has been up, whether it was reposted, how specific it is, recent company news, and whether a real person can tell you about the role.
Are ghost jobs illegal?
Generally not. Some places have started to act: Ontario, Canada now requires public job postings to say whether the role is an existing vacancy, and bills have been proposed in several US states.
Start free
Read next
How long after a job is posted should you apply? We tracked 154,000 roles
Apply within 2 to 4 days if you can. Most applications arrive in the first 96 hours, and roles go live on weekday afternoons (Eastern). Here is the data.
Easy Apply vs the company website: where should you apply?
Easy Apply is fast; the company website goes straight into the company's system. What each is good for, and a simple rule for when to use which.